This from a sleepy reader:
Midnight and I can’t get to sleep until I ask this question: what’s wrong with Callie? I understand that she’s been abandoned by everyone she’s ever loved, but I just can’t get at the core of her, and it’s keeping me up at night! She’s so shut down, emotionally. She’s a volcano ready to go off. Can you please speak plainly about her? Thanks. My second or third time reading though the series and it’s new to me every time. Love, love, love these books.
It goes against the grain to answer questions like this. Generally it’s up to you, as reader, to interpret the story as you see fit. You might decide that Ethan has been replaced by an alien and is working undercover to arrange the destruction of mankind. I doubt you could convince me, but I couldn’t tell you you’re wrong. If that’s where the story went for you, then that’s the end of that. You may have a theory I find hard to fathom, but that is your right.
So let’s look at Ethan and Callie.
Things you know for sure:
- Ethan lived in Manhattan for two years because his uncle Todd’s will demanded it of him. He didn’t return to Paradise in that time.
- He’s a friendly guy, and so he will have made friends. He sees Martha Kirby quite regularly, and tutors her. He’s very attached to the Spencer family, which is where Martha lives as the Spencers are her guardians.
- He leaves New York to return to Paradise quite suddenly.
- Once back in Paradise there’s no talk of friends in Manhattan, no overt sign of letter writing, no visitors. He is, essentially, without immediate family though he always included in the Bonner family affairs as Elizabeth’s nephew.
- He dedicates himself, all his energy and resources, into putting the village back on its feet after years of decline. His small circle of friends includes Callie ad Daniel, Blue-Jay and Runs-from-Bears and Nathaniel.
- In all the time you’ve known him, he has never shown interest in the opposite sex.
- Martha is back in Paradise too, and eventually Jemima shows up ready to make trouble, as usual.
- Jemima lets it be known that she did some investigating in Manhattan and knows all about Martha’s sad little engagement. In fact, she visited Martha’s fiance’s mother and put an end to the whole ridiculous undertaking. Why she did this isn’t immediately apparent.
- About the same time Jemima lets it be known that she investigated Martha while in New York, she says she did the same for Ethan. She voices this in a threatening way.
- Ethan lives on his own and is lonely. he sees Callie as someone he likes and admires, and someone who needs his help. Marriages have been founded on far worse foundations, and if he can get her to agree, they will both be better off.
- Because his experience is wider and he is lonely, he recognizes that same problem in her.
- Callie has never shown interest in the opposite sex, either.
- When Martha marries suddenly, Callie feels hugely betrayed and rejected.
- Ethan may recognize this reaction as founded in something other than sisterly affection.
- Ethan capitalizes on the opportunity: he couches his proposal in terms that Callie can live with, and offers her things that she needs and wants. Friendship not least among them.
- They marry and make a stable, peaceful, kind home where they raise Jennet and Luke’s children. And they never sleep in the same bed.
So read through this list and then ask yourself the question: what was the basis of Ethan and Callie’s relationship?